Appeals: guide
Help release c4e6d48f22a45602 · Generated 22 November 2026. Online at docs.mycadesk.in/modules/appeals/.
Help explains how the software works and is not professional advice; refer to the statute or notification.
Intimations, appeals and proceedings
Analyse intimations against the client's own figures, run case files for assessments, prepare and decide appeals, and keep the demand register and stays. Dates always come from the notice register.
This area builds on the notice register: every notice, order and date it uses is kept there, and nothing here keeps a copy. Litigation work is for staff only; nothing here is shown in the client portal.
The parts
| Tab | What you do there |
|---|---|
| Intimations | Compare the department's figures with the return or computation, decide each variance and draft the reply. See Intimations to analyse. |
| Appeals | Open an appeal from an appealable order, enter the amounts in dispute and grounds, assemble the pack, decide and record the filing. See Appeals. |
| Proceedings | One case file per scrutiny, reassessment or penalty proceeding: stage, issues, hearings, response packs. See Proceedings case files. |
| Demands | The ledger of each demand, its payments and reductions, and stays. See The demand register. |
| Reply templates | Platform starters and the firm's own templates. See Reply templates. |
| Settings | The firm's choices for this area. See Intimations and appeals settings. |
Principles
- People confirm, the app suggests. Figures read from a file are proposals until a person confirms them; recommendations are labelled "Suggested, review before acting".
- A second person checks. Approvals and decisions are made by someone other than the preparer (a solo practice is exempt and the exception is recorded).
- Partners decide. Whether to file an appeal, concede an issue, apply for a stay or choose a penalty option is a partner's decision with a fresh identity check, unless the firm lets managers decide too.
- Amounts are keyed, never computed. Demands and penalties are entered as the notice states them. The pre-deposit and appeal fee are shown, never collected.
- The app never files. You file on the department's portal and record it here.
Parts switched on separately
Intimation analysis, and GST intimations within it, are switched on for a firm during roll-out. While GST intimations are off, GST intimation types cannot be analysed.
Analyse an intimation
Confirm the intimation's figures, compare them with the return or computation, decide each variance, get the analysis approved and draft a reply that is attached to the notice.
1. Confirm the figures
Under Figures on the intimation, check the reference, DIN and identifier as printed (the identifier is checked against the notice, not stored), then type or check both columns, As provided in return and As computed, for each line.
- Save draft keeps a proposal; it is not yet an intimation figure.
- Confirm figures makes them the intimation's figures. Lines you changed from a value read from the file keep the read value as a record.
Later edits are kept in a history and put the analysis back to open.
2. Run the analysis
The analysis compares each line with the client's own figures: a figure you pinned, the return as filed, an imported ITR JSON or the income computation, in that order, or the figures as provided per the intimation. It lists the Variances with their difference, explanations found (exact, partial or unexplained) and a recommended action (accept, rectify, respond, appeal, revise the return, investigate). Variances below the firm's materiality are marked immaterial.
The analysis runs by itself on confirmation if the firm chose that; otherwise run it from Analysis.
3. Decide and approve
- Record a Decision on each variance that needs one. A decision that departs from the recommendation needs a reason of at least 20 characters.
- Approve analysis: the approver cannot be the person who confirmed the figures or the last person who decided a variance (unless the firm switched the reviewer off, or is a solo practice).
- Reopen an approved analysis with a reason to change it.
Recommendations are suggestions; nothing here is shared with the client.
4. Draft the reply
Under Drafts, choose New draft: the kind of letter (for example a rectification request or a response to a proposed adjustment), the template and the signatory. Preview shows the text and any field without a value. Create draft renders it as DOCX and PDF and files it in Documents. Then choose Attach to the notice: the draft becomes a draft reply on the notice, and the register's reply steps (approve, record as filed, close) apply. See Work on a notice.
Answer a notice with a response pack
Key the questions of a notice, answer each with text and evidence, and build a response pack (covering letter, index and annexures in parts that fit the portal) to attach to the notice.
Questions
Steps
- Choose Key the questions and enter them one per line, as numbered in the notice.
- For each question, write the response, add evidence (documents of the client in Documents) and set its status.
Build a response pack
Under Build a response pack, tick the questions to include, choose the kind, the covering letter template and the signatory, and choose Build pack. The pack is assembled in the background: the covering letter, then the index, then the annexures in question order, with page numbers and bookmarks, cut into parts within the target portal's limits. The same inputs always give the same pack.
Response packs lists each pack with its index and annexures. A pack that could not be assembled says why and which documents were refused. Discard a pack you will not use; editing an item in a pack replaces it.
Attach and submit
Choose Attach to the notice. The pack becomes a reply on the notice in the register, where its reviewer approves it; the reviewer cannot be one of the pack's editors (unless the firm is a solo practice). File it on the portal yourself and record it as filed on the notice: the pack, its questions and the linked issues are then marked as submitted.
Appeals
List the firm's appeals by forum, status and last date, and open an appeal from an appealable order in the notice register.
The list shows each appeal with its client, forum, status and last date to appeal; Late marks an appeal past its last date and Needs the service date one whose deadline cannot be worked out yet. Filter by Forum, Status or Last date (within 30 days).
Open an appeal
Steps
- Choose Open an appeal.
- Choose the Order. The order stays in the notice register, and its appeal deadline is the register's.
- Choose the Forum offered for the order: a first appeal (Form 35, or APL-01 for GST) or a tribunal.
- Choose Open appeal.
An appeal opened from a case file's order takes the issues confirmed in the order as draft grounds (see Work a case file). A second appeal to a tribunal keeps the record, the deadline and the pre-deposit only; the app prepares no form pack for it.
Intimations to analyse
List the intimations being analysed, start an analysis from a notice in the register, or upload an intimation file so it is registered and read in one step.
The list shows each intimation with its client, year, status and how many variances are unexplained or have a recommendation. Inputs changed means something the analysis used has changed since it ran (for example a newer Form 26AS was imported); run it again. Filter by Status or Explanations (with unexplained variances).
Start from a notice in the register
Steps
- Choose Analyse an intimation.
- Choose the Notice. The client, year and identifier are taken from it.
- Choose Start analysis.
The income-tax intimation and the proposed adjustment can be analysed and, when GST intimations are switched on for the firm, GST DRC-01B, DRC-01C and ASMT-10.
Upload an intimation file
Steps
- Choose Upload an intimation.
- Choose the type, the year or tax period, the date and the date of service.
- Add the PDF password if the file has one. It is used once and not kept.
- Choose the Intimation PDF and Upload.
The file is scanned, filed in the notice register as a notice, and then read by the platform. What is read is only a proposal: you check and confirm the figures on the intimation's page. If the file cannot be read (an unknown layout, a wrong password, an identifier that is not the client's), type the figures instead.
Prepare, decide and record an appeal
Enter the amounts in dispute, compute the pre-deposit and fee, write grounds, draft the appeal documents, assemble the pack, record the partner's decision, the filing and the outcome.
Limitation
Limitation (notice register) shows the order date, the date of service, the last date to appeal and the condonable date, read from the register. See Appeal deadlines and late appeals (sign in to read).
Amounts in dispute
Enter, by head and component, the amount Demanded, Admitted and Paid; the disputed amount follows. Add the assessed income where the appeal fee depends on it. Changing the amounts makes an earlier pre-deposit calculation out of date.
Pre-deposit and fee
Choose Compute. The page shows, per component, what is required before the appeal is admitted, what is paid and the shortfall, and the appeal fee. It is shown, never collected. A partner can Record payment reference for a payment made on the portal, which clears a shortfall.
Grounds and documents
- Grounds of appeal: add, edit or remove grounds.
- Appeal documents: draft the grounds, statement of facts, condonation application or stay request from a template (Draft from the platform starter) with a signatory. Drafts are filed in Documents and join the pack.
Pack and decision
Steps
- Add a Condonation statement if the appeal is late.
- Choose Assemble pack. The pack lists any blockers (see The appeal pack has blockers (sign in to read)).
- A partner (or a manager, if the firm allows) chooses Decide: File the appeal or Do not file (with a reason), and confirms it's them. The person who prepared the appeal cannot decide it, unless the firm is a solo practice.
Only a partner can Override the time bar, with a reason. Editing the appeal after the pack makes the pack out of date.
Filing and outcome
File the appeal on the portal yourself. Then Record filing: the filing date and the acknowledgement number (or an acknowledgement file). In the same step the notice register closes the order as appealed and opens the appeal proceeding; if the register refuses, nothing is recorded. Later, Record outcome with the appellate order. An adverse outcome can lead to a second appeal opened from that order.
Withdraw an appeal with a reason of at least 20 characters.
Proceedings case files
List the case files of scrutiny, reassessment, penalty and GST proceedings by kind, status and coming hearings, and open a case file from a proceeding in the notice register.
The list shows each case file with its client, kind, stage (Override when someone set it by hand), open issues and whether the assessment is faceless. Filter by Kind, Status or Hearing (within 7 days).
Open a case file
Steps
- Choose Open a case file.
- Choose the Proceeding from the notice register.
- Choose Open case file.
The client, identifier, law, period and kind are copied from the proceeding, never typed. The proceeding, its notices and dates stay in the notice register. If the firm opens case files by themselves, one already exists for each scrutiny or reassessment proceeding (see Intimations and appeals settings).
Reply templates
Use the platform's reviewed starters or write the firm's own templates for replies, covering letters and appeal documents. Another member activates a firm template.
Platform starters
Starters are written by the platform and appear once a CA has reviewed them. They are read-only and labelled "platform starter — review before use". Copy to firm makes an editable firm draft from one.
Firm templates
Steps
- Choose New firm template (or copy a starter).
- Enter a Key (lower case, for example
firm_covering_letter), a Title, the Kind of letter and the Body. Use fields in double braces, such as{{client.name}}, and lists such as{{#variance}}…{{/variance}}. Never put client data in the template itself. - Save draft.
- Another member chooses Activate (maker-checker); a solo practice may activate its own.
Firm templates are labelled "firm-authored, not platform-verified". Retire a template you no longer use. The firm can choose to allow drafts only from platform starters.
Stay of demand
Prepare a stay application, record the partner's decision to file, the filing and the stay order, and end the stay. The end date is kept by the notice register.
A stay starts as a draft from a demand (Apply for a stay). It covers demands of one client and law, may name the appeal, and shows a proposed payment based on the administrative guideline (not statutory).
Steps
- Record the partner's decision to file, with a reason and a fresh identity check. Whoever prepared the application cannot decide it.
- File the application on the portal or with the officer yourself, then Record the filing with the date applied.
- Key the stay order in the notice register with its stay-until date, then Record the stay order with that notice id: granted, partly granted or rejected. Accepting instalment conditions is a partner's decision.
- End the stay when it ends (with a reason) or is vacated by an order.
The register keeps the end date and sends the reminders; the stay page shows it under Ends (notice register). A stay filed more than 30 days ago without an order is flagged. For a GST appeal filed with the pre-deposit paid in full, a stay Deemed on the appeal is recorded by itself and ends when the appeal is decided.
The demand register
Record each demand as the order states it, keep a ledger of payments, reductions and set-offs, see what is outstanding by year and head, and apply for a stay.
The register
The list shows each demand with its status (outstanding, partly paid, stayed, under appeal, paid, reduced to nil, written back) and what is outstanding. Not linked to a notice marks a line imported from the portal's outstanding-demand list that still needs its notice. Outstanding by year and head totals what is raised and outstanding, and Stays lists stays with any that have expired or have no order yet.
Outstanding amounts are worked out from each demand's ledger. Interest is not computed here.
Record a demand
Choose Record demand, give the notice id of the order or demand notice in the notice register, and key the lines (component, head, amount) as it states them. Nothing is computed.
A demand
- Lines show, per line, what was raised, paid, reduced and is outstanding.
- Record event adds a ledger event: a payment (with its payment reference), a refund set off, an enhancement, a reduction (on rectification, by an order giving effect to an appeal, or by another order) or a write-back. A reduction needs its order in the register, or a second person confirms it with Confirm when the firm requires that.
- Link to a notice connects an imported line to its demand notice.
- Apply for a stay starts a stay application (see Stay of demand).
Work a case file
Follow a proceeding's stage and notices, keep the issue register, record hearings and their outcomes, check reopening safeguards, handle penalty options and open an appeal from the order.
Stage and notices
The Stage is worked out from the notices received and the events recorded. A manager can Override stage with a reason of at least 20 characters; the override lasts until a later notice maps to a later stage. Notices of the proceeding lists each notice with its dates, questions and status; open the response workspace from a notice to answer it (see Answer a notice with a response pack).
Issue register
One list of what the department alleges, carried from the notice that raised it to the order and, if appealed, into the appeal grounds.
- Add an issue: what is alleged, the notice it was raised in, the head and the amount as in the notice.
- change status with the notice or order it comes from. Conceding gives up a right: a partner decides, with a fresh identity check and a reason of at least 20 characters.
For a reassessment, the Reopening safeguards checklist records what was checked (for example whether the information was supplied with the show-cause notice); an unmet safeguard can be added to the issue register as a procedural issue.
Hearings
- Record a hearing request made on the portal (the request itself is made there).
- Set the date in the register: the date is saved on the notice, which sends the reminders.
- Record the outcome: who attended, the authorisation, a note (no meeting links) and, if directed, the date written submissions are due, which becomes the notice's stated date.
Penalty and options
A penalty case file shows the penalty section and limb, the initiating order, the proposed penalty (as keyed), the option windows from the notice register and, where available, Assess the conditions for immunity or a GST payment option. A partner records the decision (apply for immunity, contest or take the option) with a reason; whoever prepared the detail cannot decide it. Options are shown, never taken by the app.
Order, appeal and close
From an order in the case file, Open an appeal from this order: issues confirmed in the order become draft grounds. The Demands of the proceeding and the Timeline of everything recorded are shown below. Close case file with an outcome when the proceeding ends.
Intimations and appeals settings
The firm's choices for intimation analysis, who decides appeals and case-file questions, opening case files, demand reductions and the portal limits response packs follow.
Open Settings in the Intimations tabs. Each setting shows its current value and its default. Partners and firm administrators can change them; others see them read-only. Some settings (those that remove a review or let managers decide) can be changed only by the owner or a partner, who may be asked to confirm it's them (Step-up). Every change is recorded in the audit log.
| Setting | Default | What it does |
|---|---|---|
Materiality (₹) appeals.materiality_inr | 100 | Variances below this amount are shown as immaterial. It can only raise the platform's value (100 to 10,00,000). |
A reviewer approves every analysis appeals.analysis.reviewer_required | on | Someone other than the person who confirmed the figures or decided the last variance approves the analysis. Off: drafts can be made before approval. |
Analyse when the figures are confirmed appeals.auto_analyse_on_confirm | on | Runs the analysis straight after confirmation when there is something to compare with. |
Managers may decide appeals appeals.decide.grant_managers | off | Off: only partners decide whether to file. On: managers may too, never on an appeal they prepared. |
Open a case file for every scrutiny or reassessment proceeding appeals.matter.auto_open | on | When the notice register opens such a proceeding, a case file is opened with it. |
Managers may take case-file decisions appeals.matter.decide.grant_managers | off | Off: only partners concede an issue and take other case-file decisions. On: managers may too, with a fresh identity check. |
A second person confirms demand reductions appeals.demand.reduction_needs_second_person | on | A reduction not backed by an order in the notice register waits for a second person (a solo practice is exempt). |
Portal limits for response packs appeals.pack.target_portal_default | Income-tax e-proceeding | The portal whose part size and count limits a response pack follows unless the pack names another. |